Chapter 5: The Insults
Backstage, Catherine caught Jonathan and Ashley as they walked out.
“Dr. Vale, you know very well this is my research,” Catherine blocked his path. She had no other connections in this field; Jonathan Vale had been her only one. She had trusted him, and that made this betrayal sting all the more.
Jonathan glanced around. Ashley stood by, inspecting her long acrylic nails, a faint smirk playing on her lips. Without lifting a single finger, that woman had managed to steal her work, and her name stood beside Catherine’s now.
Who’s the real talent here, huh?
Before Catherine could speak, Jonathan gripped her arm and pulled her into one of the empty rooms.
“You’ve done excellent groundwork, Cathy, but Ashley has the network, the investors, the name. You’ve gotta know how this works. Try to understand, Cathy. You’ll get a mention on the final paper, of course.”
Catherine’s fingers tightened slightly. She forced a polite smile. “So, she gets the stage when it’s over, and I get… acknowledgment.”
Her phone rang; she silenced it.
“Recognition isn’t just about discovery, it’s about visibility. You’re young; you’ll have your turn. But right now, Helios needs funding, and Ashley’s father sits on the board of BioQuant. They’re willing to absorb us. It’s a strategy, not betrayal.”
He said it so smoothly she almost believed it… almost.
“Strategy,” Catherine repeated, her voice low and steady, the word tasting bitter on her tongue.
He looked at her then, really looked, and smiled the way men did when they thought they still had the upper hand. “You’re too bright to let pride get in the way, Cath. You want a future here? Be smart. Play along.”
As he spoke, Ashley walked in, chin tilted, every step a quiet declaration of entitlement. She knew she was well-connected, and she had the means to get what she wanted, even if it meant stealing it.
“Is this about funding then?” Catherine asked.
If only they had been honest from the start. But now… He hadn’t just betrayed her. He had traded her years of work, her credibility, for Ashley’s father’s influence and BioQuant’s money.
Her phone buzzed again. It was her father calling. She turned it face down.
“Are you begging her, Jonathan?” Ashley asked lightly. Catherine glanced at him; he said nothing. It was as if Ashley had bought even his right to speak.
Catherine’s jaw clenched. She had once thought Jonathan was someone to admire. Someone with integrity.
Ashley’s laugh was soft, almost musical; the kind people mistook for kindness until they caught the edge beneath it. She tilted her head, her gaze sweeping over Catherine’s high-collared blouse and tea-length skirt with idle curiosity, as though examining an outdated exhibit.
“What worth are you, really?” she asked sweetly, brushing an invisible speck from Catherine’s shoulder. “With your matronly aesthetics and that… almost-clever brain of yours? It’s adorable, really. You look like you got lost on your way from your father’s barn to the faculty lounge.”
Her smile deepened, perfectly rehearsed. “But this isn’t the countryside, darling. This is academia. People don’t get by on sincerity and hard work here. They get by on legacy.”
She trailed her fingers over the lace of Catherine’s sleeve with mock admiration. “A thrifted vintage Dior, is it? Charming. I’m sure it’ll turn a few heads… among the interns. But investors? They prefer people with last names that open doors, not ones still learning which fork to use at dinner.”
Ashley stepped back, her perfume cloying and expensive. “Still,” she added, voice dipped in honey, “it’s nice that you’re trying. Every institution needs a success story to keep the donors feeling generous.”
Catherine’s phone buzzed again. She ignored it, but Ashley’s eyes flicked down to the screen and caught the caller ID. Her lips curved. “Oh,” she said softly. “Daddy is calling again?”
She tilted her head with feigned sympathy. “How sweet. He must still think hard work can fix everything.”
Lowering her voice just enough for only Catherine to hear, she added, “You really should answer, Catherine. Men like your Daddy
don’t understand how easily their daughters get replaced in this world.”
Replaced.
Catherine’s heart squeezed in pain hearing that word.
Oh, she knew how easily a woman could be replaced. It was the same then. It was the same now.
Her spirit got broken. She clutched her hands so hard they shook. No matter what she did, how hard she had tried, this is where she ended up. In both lives… she ended up here…
Alone, betrayed…
Her phone kept buzzing. Through the glass wall, she saw people watching, those with curious eyes and hungry whispers. Ashley wasn’t done. She never was. Every word that left her mouth felt like another pin driven into Catherine’s skin.
Catherine finally answered the call and walked out of the room. Her father never called twice unless it mattered. “Daddy…”
“How’s my Bitty Bean doing? Did it all go well?” James Preston’s deep, loving voice filled her ear, warm enough to thaw something inside her.
Her throat tightened. She couldn’t answer. She wanted to cry, to collapse into his voice, but she wouldn’t worry him. “It went well,” she managed, softly. “Daddy, you kept calling me.” Her tone slipped into that old drawl, the one she could never hide when she talked to him.
“Did you hear her?” Ashley’s laughter rang behind her. “What a wild imagination for a country bumpkin! Is daddy’s lil’ gal going to get the Nobel prize? Look at her!” she said, loud enough for everyone to hear.
Catherine’s nails dug into her palms. In her last life, she had been a queen. In this one, she was a joke, a country bumpkin.
“Daddy?” she said again, her accent thickening. If this was how they saw her, so be it. What difference had her brilliance made, if they never saw past her roots?
“Are you alright, Bean? You sound… wrong.”
A small smile broke through her shaking lips. Of course, her daddy knew. He always knew. He had loved her with the gentleness of a man who thought she was his second chance at life.
“I’m fine, Daddy,” she said, lifting her chin as she walked down the hall. Eyes followed her, whispering, and judging, but she refused to bow.
She still had her father. She still had home. Not everything was lost.
“Alright, here it is,” James said, his voice softening for her. “You’ll be greeted by Hilbert Calhoun at the door. Go on a date with him, will ya? See how it goes.”
Catherine blinked. A blind date? Now? She almost laughed. So that’s what this was… her father’s attempt at matchmaking, even now.
She knew her father was worried for her since she never dated, and she was different from other kids who were just being “kids”. She just focused on her studies. But for him to go this far… She was just 21.
A bright lime-green sports car screeched to a stop at the entrance. A man in flamboyant designer clothes stepped out, spinning his sunglasses in one hand, gold chains glinting under the sun.
He pointed at her. “Caroline Preston?”
Catherine blinked, pulling the phone away from her ear. “Catherine,” she corrected flatly. “Mr. Calhoun?”
“Yours truly!” he said, giving an extravagant bow. His entire being was a sharp contrast to the academic, serious aura around.
She almost winced at that kid. What a peacock!
Her call had already ended. That meant her father wanted this. That meant she’d try. And maybe, just maybe, walking out with this kid, this loud, ridiculous kid, was her way of leaving with her head high. He was clearly rich. The kind of rich that made people turn heads.
And right now, she needed the world to see her leave, not crumble, even if she was shattered into a million pieces inside. She might have lost her credibility and might never be accepted back in academia, but she still had her pride.
And maybe… she might see the man beneath that flamboyance, something her dear father had seen.
And about those research thieves… she had a plan to handle them.
Catherine stepped into the car, the hem of her skirt brushing the doorframe. Hilbert grinned, revved the engine, and the car sped off under the gaze of a hundred watching eyes.
Jonathan looked at Catherine leaving so gracefully. “How in the world did she know someone like that?” he asked.
Ashley too furrowed her brows. That woman knew nothing but locking herself in her work. She never even went out for drinks, since she was underage, and she wouldn’t go out to enjoy herself. How did she manage to find some second-generation wealthy man?
“Do you think your plan will work?” Jonathan whispered.
Source: Webnovel.com, updated by NovelKeep
Chapters
- Chapter 175: To Stand Up For Her
- Chapter 174: Does Past Matter?
- Chapter 173: Her First Love?!
- Chapter 172: To Say His Name
- Chapter 171: Say My Name
- Chapter 170: Father’s Approval
- Chapter 169: His Reply
- Chapter 168: To Give Her What She Wished For
- Chapter 167: Regret So Powerful
- Chapter 166: Trusting Him More And More
- Chapter 165: The Name That Followed Him Into History
- Chapter 164: To Remember
- Chapter 163: Unlike Past Life...
- Chapter 162: Enemies Within
- Chapter 161: Built Different
- Chapter 160: Simmering Resentment
- Chapter 159: Could It Be Maximilian?
- Chapter 158: Who Is Leon Aureus?
- Chapter 157: A Familiar Name
- Chapter 156: Jonathan’s Approval
- Chapter 155: To Elope?
- Chapter 154: The Ring
- Chapter 153: Why He Broke Up With Her
- Chapter 152: A Quiet Morning
- Chapter 151: To Protect Him
- Chapter 150: Need For Revenge
- Chapter 149: Mother’s Hurt
- Chapter 148: The Accusation
- Chapter 147: Did He Buy A Ring Already?
- Chapter 146: A Forgotten Memory
- Chapter 145: Choices
- Chapter 144: He Came
- Chapter 143: His Resolution, Her Breaking
- Chapter 142: His Redemption
- Chapter 141: To Find Her
- Chapter 140: The Clingy Child
- Chapter 139: Choosing To Trust Again
- Chapter 138: Breaking Softly
- Chapter 137: Yes Or No?
- Chapter 136: Give Him What?!
- Chapter 135: Losing Control
- Chapter 134: Caged By Family
- Chapter 133: Please, Say Yes
- Chapter 132: The Popular Boyfriend
- Chapter 131: Her Doubt
- Chapter 130: Forming Factions, Breaking Trust
- Chapter 129: Secrets Revealed
- Chapter 128: The Slap
- Chapter 127: The Interrogation
- Chapter 126: The Café Confrontation
- Chapter 125: A Door Opened
- Chapter 124: Dorian’s Announcement
- Chapter 123: Taking Control
- Chapter 122: He Was Jealous
- Chapter 121: Babysitting
- Chapter 120: Since Eighteen
- Chapter 119: King Again
- Chapter 118: Happy Father, Happy Family
- Chapter 117: The Beckoning
- Chapter 116: Losing Control
- Chapter 115: An Uncontrollable Visitor
- Chapter 114: To Stay
- Chapter 113: The Glue Of The Family
- Chapter 112: His Longing
- Chapter 111: Predators In Silk
- Chapter 110: A Father’s Hope
- Chapter 109: Every Inch A Queen
- Chapter 108: The Man She Had Never Truly Seen
- Chapter 107: Is Redemption Possible?
- Chapter 106: The Reason
- Chapter 105: Moment Of Truth
- Chapter 104: Loved Up
- Chapter 103: Kisses Weren’t Enough
- Chapter 102: Can’t Escape
- Chapter 101: The Truth
- Chapter 100: His Quiet Obsession
- Chapter 99: To Be Free
- Chapter 98: Choosing Herself
- Chapter 97: Obsessive Plea
- Chapter 96: Meeting Dorian
- Chapter 95: To Stay Together
- Chapter 94: Love or Fear?
- Chapter 93: For You, My Queen
- Chapter 92: To Get Advice
- Chapter 91: Protective Instinct
- Chapter 90: Dorian’s Move
- Chapter 89: He Stayed
- Chapter 88: A Solemn Promise and Fractured Memories
- Chapter 87: To Communicate
- Chapter 86: Finally Found Each Other
- Chapter 85: Bernice & Sebastian
- Chapter 84: The Retaliation
- Chapter 83: Gabriel’s Proposal
- Chapter 82: The Meeting
- Chapter 81: The Phone Call
- Chapter 80: The Vow Ribbon Incident
- Chapter 79: Were They On The Same Side?
- Chapter 78: Failing Restraint
- Chapter 77: Morning Shenanigans
- Chapter 76: A Quiet Warmth
- Chapter 75: A Peaceful Night?!
- Chapter 74: Caught
- Chapter 73: Queen Without A Crown
- Chapter 72: Intoxicating Darkness
- Chapter 71: The War Queen Awakens
- Chapter 70: Fragments Of Past
- Chapter 69: Body Vs Heart Vs Mind
- Chapter 68: To Belong To Each Other
- Chapter 67: Will He? Won’t He?
- Chapter 66: The Winthorp Legacy Dinner (11)
- Chapter 65: The Winthorp Legacy Dinner(10)
- Chapter 64: The Winthorp Legacy Dinner (9)- First Meeting
- Chapter 63: The Winthorp Legacy Dinner (8)
- Chapter 62: The Winthorp Legacy Dinner (7)
- Chapter 61: The Winthorp Legacy Dinner(6)
- Chapter 60: The Winthorp Legacy Dinner(5)
- Chapter 59: The Winthorp Legacy Dinner(4)
- Chapter 58: The Winthorp Legacy Dinner (3)
- Chapter 57: The Winthorp Legacy Dinner (2)
- Chapter 56: The Winthorp Legacy Dinner (1)
- Chapter 55: Family Dynamics
- Chapter 54: The Blackwood Heir
- Chapter 53: Rising Hunger
- Chapter 52: Her Strategy
- Chapter 51: To Move Away
- Chapter 50: Her Resolution
- Chapter 49: To Confront The Truth
- Chapter 48: Warping Rules, Fracturing Logic
- Chapter 47: Too Stuck In The Past?!
- Chapter 46: Solving Problems
- Chapter 45: Was That... Jealousy?!
- Chapter 44: To Break The Shackle
- Chapter 43: The Soul Shackle
- Chapter 42: Nostalgic Memories
- Chapter 41: Sleeping Arrangements
- Chapter 40: Worlds Apart
- Chapter 39: Pinned Underneath Him
- Chapter 38: A Love Strong Enough
- Chapter 37: Alexander’s Choice
- Chapter 36: The One She Couldn’t Lie To
- Chapter 35: To Court Her
- Chapter 34: Crashing Down
- Chapter 33: To Admit Attraction Or Not
- Chapter 32: The Lullaby
- Chapter 31: Her Name
- Chapter 30: Cleaver And Ice
- Chapter 29: Who’d Blink First?
- Chapter 28: Domestic Bliss? Nah... It’s Got To Be A Hallucination
- Chapter 27: A Nightmare Life
- Chapter 26: Shackled, To Him
- Chapter 25: Another Familiar Face
- Chapter 24: A Perfect Proposal
- Chapter 23: The Bracelet
- Chapter 22: Use My Name
- Chapter 21: The Third Option
- Chapter 20: Breaking Down
- Chapter 19: Sebastian Remington
- Chapter 18: Lying With Precision
- Chapter 17: A Man Who Protected What Was His
- Chapter 16: The Confession
- Chapter 15: Have We Met Before?
- Chapter 14: Stepping Toward The Past
- Chapter 13: Locked Out
- Chapter 12: Alexander’s Priority
- Chapter 11: A Tender Kiss
- Chapter 10: When An Unstoppable Force Meets An Immovable Object
- Chapter 9: Roxana - An Immovable Object
- Chapter 8: Hunter Alex - The Unstoppable Force
- Chapter 7: He Returned
- Chapter 6: Reaching Rock-bottom
- Chapter 5: The Insults
- Chapter 4: Present Life: Getting Erased
- Chapter 3: Past Life - The Last Stand
- Chapter 2: Past Life - The Betrayal
- Chapter 1: Past Life - The Promise